PDA

View Full Version : [Jingle] XEP-0177 typo: missing component attribute in section 4.2


Senko Rasic
11-09-2008, 12:22 PM
Hi,

the XEP defines required "component" attribute for raw-udp
candidates, but section 4.2 doesn't mention it, so unless
one looks at the schema definition, it looks like that
attribute is optional and used only if there are several
candidates specified.

This should be clarified in 4.2 (if the intention is to
require it, then explicitly state it, if not, fix the
schema and explicitly state it's optional and default is
"1" (RTP).

Regards,
Senko

Peter Saint-Andre
11-13-2008, 07:18 AM
Senko Rasic wrote:

> the XEP defines required "component" attribute for raw-udp
> candidates, but section 4.2 doesn't mention it, so unless
> one looks at the schema definition, it looks like that
> attribute is optional and used only if there are several
> candidates specified.
>
> This should be clarified in 4.2 (if the intention is to
> require it, then explicitly state it, if not, fix the
> schema and explicitly state it's optional and default is
> "1" (RTP).

Fixed in XEP-0177. The 'component' attribute is required, so that
example was wrong (not updated along with the others).

/psa